Skip to content
Rebekah Barton
Menu
  • Home
  • About Me
Menu

A Magical Christmas at The Cake Bake Shop

Posted on November 14, 2022November 14, 2022 by Rebekah

If you’re anything like me, you spent your childhood dressing up as an adventurous Princess who explored enchanted forests every day and went home to a fabulously-decorated palace at night. But we all know that’s not real life — at least until you visit The Cake Bake Shop in Indianapolis.

cake bake shop carmel city center entry

We most recently visited the Carmel City Center location. Indianapolis locals and travelers can also enjoy the Broad Ripple Village shop, which is equally magical.

Created by Gwendolyn Rogers, the storybook bakery is straight out of Rodgers and Hammerstein. You almost expect Prince Charming to come sweep you away, at least until midnight, from the moment you walk through the French doors.

chandeliers and christmas garland on the ceiling at the cake bake shop in indianapolis

When we visited in early November, we were delighted to discover that the fairytale bakery was already adorned for Christmas — I don’t know if my daughters or I were more excited!

I don’t hesitate to say that The Cake Bake Shop is the single best location for girls’ day out in the Indianapolis area.

two women in festive casual outfits outside of cake bake shop indianapolis two adult sisters laughing with arms around each other by a Christmas tree mother and two daughters laughing and posing outside of cake bake shop indianapolis

Either location offers a whimsical experience that will transport you into another world for a couple of hours while you sip glitter-embellished cappuccinos (!), and dine on some of the most delicious food and desserts you’ve ever been served.

woman sipping cappuccino at the cake bake shop in indianpolis

While most people familiar with Gwendolyn’s vision for The Cake Bake Shop already know about the brand’s signature melt-in-your-mouth cakes, fewer people realize that the establishment is a full-service restaurant, as well!

Our party of five — myself, my best friend, my sister, and both of my daughters — enjoyed coffee, lunch, and dessert on our most recent excursion. Between us, we tried several dishes, including leek pasta, a Caesar salad with salmon, and the Sunday soup du jour.

My 3-year-old also devoured the French fries (you’ll see one peeking out of corner below!)

You can view the full Carmel location menu here.

soup bowl on a white plate with bread and butter dish

While waiting on dessert, we couldn’t resist taking photos in the adorable swan sleigh The Cake Bake Shop has set up for the holiday season. If you’re looking to save money on Christmas card photos this year, you could actually take the perfect picture of your family at this elegant photo spot.

Even the candids of my daughters turned out well — and if you’re a mom, you know what a win that is. The girls wanted to take the swan home with us, as you can see from their smiles.

two little girls in swan sleigh by christmas tree at the cake bake shop indianapolis little girl in cardigan and pink hairbow with arms outstretched smiling little girl hugging the neck of a swan sleigh

As for dessert, my sister and I both ordered the champagne raspberry cake, while my friend enjoyed the seasonal pumpkin chocolate cake. Both options were as incredible as expected.

Plus, each slice is topped with more edible glitter, which is my personal favorite detail!

raspberry champagne cake slice topped with glitter at the cake bake shop indianapolis

I cannot recommend an Indy-area day out at The Cake Bake Shop enough! It’s our go-to when we’re craving a fairytale escape, and I know you’ll love this magical restaurant as much as we do.

What’s Next For The Cake Bake Shop?

dining room at the cake bake shop with mercury glass artwork

As you probably know, my love for Disney Parks knows no bounds, so you can imagine how thrilled I am that The Cake Bake Shop’s next location will be at Walt Disney World Resort’s BoardWalk.

The official announcement shares the following details:

Waterside strolls will be extra special with storybook sweet treats and dreamy desserts at The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers, a new table service restaurant and bakery that’s sure to delight. Expected to open in 2023, this restaurant will offer both savory and dessert menus, along with afternoon tea service, in a whimsical atmosphere that complements the magic of the idyllic charm of Disney’s BoardWalk that guests know and love.

Have you experienced the magic of The Cake Bake Shop yet?

You Might Also Enjoy:

  • An Authentic Kentucky Experience at Origin Hotel Lexington

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Me!

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on Instagram

About Me


I’m Rebekah Barton, a lifelong lover of all things fashion and sparkly. I’m a Hoosier by birth but my heart resides in Manhattan, and I make it there as often as I possibly can. I found my place at the intersection of “mom life” and style, for the everyday woman who wants to elevate her look.

Read more here >>

Active Codes

Rebekah15 at Little Words Project (15% off)
XRWB10 at Desenio (10% off posters, no frames or custom items)
SARAHFLINT-BAREBEKAHB at Sarah Flint ($50 off your first pair of shoes)

Recent Posts

  • Shop Spotlight: Fight East African Poverty With Tuli Jewelry

    Shop Spotlight: Fight East African Poverty With Tuli Jewelry

    March 31, 2023
  • A Complete Guide to Rusacks St. Andrews Hotel

    A Complete Guide to Rusacks St. Andrews Hotel

    March 28, 2023
  • The Bridge Is a Mediterranean Oasis In the Heart of Scotland

    The Bridge Is a Mediterranean Oasis In the Heart of Scotland

    March 26, 2023
  • 18: An Incredible Dining Experience With Golf's Most Iconic View

    18: An Incredible Dining Experience With Golf's Most Iconic View

    March 22, 2023
  • Check Out One of North America's Top 50 Speakeasies In Indianapolis

    Check Out One of North America's Top 50 Speakeasies In Indianapolis

    March 9, 2023

Recent Comments

  1. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  2. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  3. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  4. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  5. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy

Archives

  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022

Categories

  • About Me
  • Disney
  • Europe
  • Family
  • Home Decor
  • Hotels
  • Indiana
  • My Picks
  • Recipes
  • Restaurants
  • Shopping
  • Speakeasies
  • Travel
© 2023 Rebekah Barton | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme