Skip to content
Rebekah Barton
Menu
  • Home
  • About Me
Menu
two drinks sitting on the bar with whiskey bottles in the background

Discover South Bend’s Hidden Gem (and It’s Close to Notre Dame)

Posted on November 28, 2022March 9, 2023 by Rebekah

When you marry a lifelong Notre Dame fan, it’s only a matter of time until you find yourself in South Bend. The city of just over 103,000 residents is largely defined by the University of Notre Dame…and its football team.

Names like Joe Theismann, Ara Parseghian, Frank Leahy, Joe Montana, George Gipp, Lou Holtz, and Knute Rockne will forever be imprinted on the storied Fighting Irish program. Even this Alabama fan has to admit that there’s something special about spending a college football Saturday at Notre Dame Stadium.

woman sitting on bleachers wearing winter gear at notre dame football game

But as much as football pervades the city, there’s a lot more to South Bend than first downs and touchdowns.

Welcome to The Exchange, a speakeasy-style bar housed in a 1913 building that was once Citizen’s Bank and Trust. With over 450 whiskeys and bourbons available, there’s no doubt you’ll return time and time — and time — again to try new concoctions.

interior of the exchange south bend with people at tables and bar

When the bar opened in 2013, owner Kurt Janowsky told the South Bend Tribune, “This is the kind of place where you can wind down after work over a glass. But I also think a lot of business and deals will be done here.”

The space — which, much to my delight, had been transformed into a winter wonderland on the day we visited — decidedly feels like the sort of place where titans of industry like J.P. Morgan and Cornelius Vanderbilt might have closed deals 100 years ago.

woman sitting on chesterfield couch placing drink on table at speakeasy bar

One of my favorite things about The Exchange is that it features both a traditional bar, complete with vintage-looking barstools, and multiple seating areas for a more intimate evening with your party.

This means you don’t have to choose between a traditional “going out” experience and feeling like you’re sitting in someone’s extremely well-decorated living room. If you want to change the vibe of your night halfway through, all you have to do is walk a few steps to the other side of the space.

winter decor at the exchange south bend speakeasy bar

Our bartender, the fabulous John, introduced us to several of the establishment’s Prohibition Era-inspired cocktails throughout our evening.

Each one was incredible in its own right but my favorite was a Mint Julep-esque drink that features tequila instead of bourbon. I know how this sounds — I love bourbon country, after all — but I was wildly impressed with the combination of flavors.

woman sitting on ottoman holding cocktail with christmas tree in background

Make sure you give this one a try next time you’re in Fighting Irish country.

I also loved the “Don’t Tell Lies In Heaven,” a drink made with Woodford Rye, Woodford Bourbon, smoked amaro, cherry, and vanilla bitters. This is the perfect cocktail for a cold evening (plus, check out that glassware).

drink sitting on the bar at the exchange south bend

We also tried the “Executive Old Fashioned”, which is presented on a smoky serving dish. The bar’s menu notes that this signature beverage is “the height of whiskey luxury,” featuring applewood smoked Rabbit Hole Dareringer PX Cask Finished Bourbon.

I cannot recommend a night — or two, or three — out at The Exchange enough. I know I’ll be back to try more Roaring Twenties cocktails next time I’m in town.

More on The Exchange Whiskey Bar

christmas trees at the exchange south bend

The Exchange South Bend is officially described as:

The original Exchange Whiskey Bar draws its inspiration from its home inside the Citizens’ Bank & Trust Building, built in 1913 and now listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Once a bank, the marble walls and wrought iron accents still make it easy to imagine where the tellers would be.

And, if you’re in the Indianapolis area, make sure you pick your poison at the brand’s Massachusetts Avenue location as well!

Which drink will you be trying first at The Exchange? Tell me in the comments!

You Might Also Enjoy:

  • Party Like It’s 1920 at John Dillinger’s Actual Speakeasy Hideout

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Follow Me!

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on Instagram

About Me


I’m Rebekah Barton, a lifelong lover of all things fashion and sparkly. I’m a Hoosier by birth but my heart resides in Manhattan, and I make it there as often as I possibly can. I found my place at the intersection of “mom life” and style, for the everyday woman who wants to elevate her look.

Read more here >>

Active Codes

Rebekah15 at Little Words Project (15% off)
XRWB10 at Desenio (10% off posters, no frames or custom items)
SARAHFLINT-BAREBEKAHB at Sarah Flint ($50 off your first pair of shoes)

Recent Posts

  • Shop Spotlight: Fight East African Poverty With Tuli Jewelry

    Shop Spotlight: Fight East African Poverty With Tuli Jewelry

    March 31, 2023
  • A Complete Guide to Rusacks St. Andrews Hotel

    A Complete Guide to Rusacks St. Andrews Hotel

    March 28, 2023
  • The Bridge Is a Mediterranean Oasis In the Heart of Scotland

    The Bridge Is a Mediterranean Oasis In the Heart of Scotland

    March 26, 2023
  • 18: An Incredible Dining Experience With Golf's Most Iconic View

    18: An Incredible Dining Experience With Golf's Most Iconic View

    March 22, 2023
  • Check Out One of North America's Top 50 Speakeasies In Indianapolis

    Check Out One of North America's Top 50 Speakeasies In Indianapolis

    March 9, 2023

Recent Comments

  1. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  2. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  3. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  4. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy
  5. rebekah on Step Inside Indy’s Only Password-Protected Speakeasy

Archives

  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022

Categories

  • About Me
  • Disney
  • Europe
  • Family
  • Home Decor
  • Hotels
  • Indiana
  • My Picks
  • Recipes
  • Restaurants
  • Shopping
  • Speakeasies
  • Travel
© 2023 Rebekah Barton | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme